"Direct military force will continue to play a role in the long-term effort against terrorists and other extremists. But over the long term, the United States cannot kill or capture its way to victory. Where possible, what the military calls kinetic operations should be subordinated to measures aimed at promoting better governance, economic programs that spur development, and efforts to address the grievances among the discontented, from whom the terrorists recruit.All in all, a very sensible realist document. However, my view is that the less the military is used as the deciding factor in the pursuit of political aims, the better. There is a limit to how much territory can effectively be administered, while developing domestic administrative capability, by the US armed forces. Either way, well worth reading in full, and an extremely welcome tone of sobriety coming from the incoming US cabinet.
But before the United States begins rearming for another Cold War, it must remember that what is driving Russia is a desire to exorcise past humiliation and dominate its 'near abroad' -- not an ideologically driven campaign to dominate the globe.
War is inevitably tragic, inefficient, and uncertain, and it is important to be skeptical of systems analyses, computer models, game theories, or doctrines that suggest otherwise. We should look askance at idealistic, triumphalist, or ethnocentric notions of future conflict that aspire to transcend the immutable principles and ugly realities of war, that imagine it is possible to cow, shock, or awe an enemy into submission, instead of tracking enemies down hilltop by hilltop, house by house, block by bloody block. As General William Tecumseh Sherman said, 'Every attempt to make war easy and safe will result in humiliation and disaster.'"
2. Will McCants at Jihadica writes that al-Shabaab in Somalia has announced the establishment of another governorate for the southern province of Lower Shabelle in southern Somalia.
"The new governorate has a governor and supervisors for missionizing and education, security and morality policing, courts, and the treasury."Al-Shabaab sees what it has done so far as "liberating" the local populace from criminal gangs which were extorting them. However, its decision to destroy the local saints shrines--which are part of the local Sufi-inspired Islam--will probably ultimately alienate many.
3. Asif Ali Zadari, President of Pakistan, has an Op-Ed in the New York Times where he argues that his government is a target of the same terrorists who attacked Mumbai. He points out that his wife was a victim of the ideological fellow-travelers of these terrorists and that, therefore, he is in a position to understand the aggrieved feelings of the people of India. He writes that Pakistan has over 150,000 soldiers engaging the Taliban in northwest Pakistan and says that the best thing the world can do to combat the menace is to support the current government, which is democratic, and provide the help it needs to build anti-terrorism capability. Worth reading in full.
4. Candace Rondeaux at the Washington Post reports that Pakistani authorities announced tey have arrested a suspected ringleader of the Mumbai attacks in Kashmir yesterday.
"Pakistani security forces arrested 22 people, including Zaki-ur-Rehman Lakhvi, one of at least five Lashkar members named by Indian authorities as the organizers of the Mumbai siege, according to local residents and a Jamaat-ud-Dawa member."There has been no independent confirmation of the arrests so far.
5. Borzou Daragahi at the Los Angeles Times has an interview with Mohamed El-Baradei, the head of the IAEA. He regards the efforts to isolate Iran in order to try and ensure that it does not use its nuclear program to build weapons a failure so far and appears to endorse a "grand bargain" solution for the impasse between the United States and Iran. I think there is little point in pursuing a grand bargain, but El-Baradei certainly has more experience in difficult diplomatic negotiations than me. Worth reading in full.
6. Steve Erlanger at the New York Times reports that the European Union is launching an effort, led by Nicolas Sarkozy, to place a global ban on all nuclear weapons testing and a suspension of all fissile material production.
7. Alex Nicholson at Bloomberg reports that the Russian Federal Statistics Service published data showing that GDP growth fell to 6.2% in the third quarter, down from 7.5% in the second. This is the slowest rate seen in three years or so. "The Economy Ministry has a forecast of 6.8% to 7% growth this year, implying 5% growth in the fourth quarter, [Chris] Weafer [a chief strategist at UralSib Financial Corp. in Moscow] said."
8. Li Yanping and Kevin Hamlin at Bloomberg report that an adviser to the People's Bank of China, Fan Gang, said today in Beijing that "November figures will come out soon, and industrial growth will be something around 5 percent and export growth will be negative."
9. Belinda Cao at Bloomberg writes that a Nomura Holdings Inc. report by Sun Mingchun argues that China will widen the yuan's daily trading band against the dollar from 0.5% to 3%.
"Sun said the yuan’s trade-weighted real effective rate gained 12.3 percent in the past four months, exceeding advances made in the two years through July, according to rates calculated by the Bank for International Settlements.10. Tony Munroe and Kevin Liffey at Reuters report that Japanese GDP contracted by 0.5% in the third quarter, a deeper cut than the previous estimate of 0.1%. In year-over-year terms, that represents a contraction of about 1.8%.
'Should the dollar start to fall versus other currencies, we’ll expect the yuan to go back on the course of appreciation,' he said."
11. Eurointelligence reports that Mercedes this week was the last German auto manufacturer to mandate compulsory reduction in labor work hours so as to reduce supply in the face of falling global demand.
12. Ian Austen at the New York Times reports that the Bank of Canada cut today its benchmark interest rate by 75 basis points (0.75%) to 1.5%. This was done with the legislative wing of the government shut down by the Parliament in order to prevent his own ouster--until late January, anyways.
13. Joshua Goodman and Andre Soliani at Bloomberg report that Brazil's GDP grew at an annual rate of 6.8% in the third quarter.
"Finance Minister Guido Mantega, speaking to reporters after the GDP report, said economic growth may slow to between 3 percent and 3.5 percent in the fourth quarter before rebounding to 4 percent growth next year. Brazil’s economy may fully recover its current growth pace in 2010, he added."Annual inflation is at 6.39% which is near the upper limit of the band set by the government of 6.5%.
14. Fabio Alves at Bloomberg reports that the investor relations manager for Petrobras told an investors conference in New York that the pre-salt fields may be able to produce oil at less than $40/b. This follows assurances by Petrobras CEO Jose Sergio Gabrielli last week that production was economic at below $50/b (see Daily Sources 12/5 #8) and a report from Banco Santander following a meeting with the manager of the pre-salt regions suggesting that Petrobras could make a profit from them at $50/b. (see Daily Sources 12/2 #11). Petrobras has approved a pilot project for the Tupi field--in the pre-salt region--which would begin production in 2010 with target production of 100 kb/d. Testing is expected to begin in March 2009 and will initially produce 15-30 kb/d.
Tupi is estimated to have between 5-8 billion barrels of oil. "The oil company this week said it raised $7.5 billion this year to finance investments. Petrobras said in a regulatory filing that it has always borrowed funds in the domestic and international markets." The investor relations manager told the conference that Petrobras in negotiating with the Chinese development bank for further financing. Given China's resource policy, the implication is that terms will be friendly. Eric Watkins at the Oil & Gas Journal reports that Mines and Energy Minister Edison Lobao gave an interview with the daily Folha de Sao Paulo that China has offered Petrobras $10 billion initially and that the UAE is also interested in financing the project. Lobao also told the state news agency that the company is still reviewing its 2009-2013 strategic plan, which is due to be released for comment by the end of the year, after the board meets to finalize it by December 19-20.
15. Nidaa Bakhsh at Bloomberg reports that Total SA is starting gasoline units at its La Mede refinery after a 2 month halt. The unit now should have a production capacity of about 35.5 kb/d and the refinery has a throughput capacity of 157 kb/d. Gasoline has been trading at a discount to Brent in London since October 1, which is part of the reason it is so cheap currently in the US.
"France was the third-largest foreign supplier of gasoline to the U.S. in September, shipping 3.58 million barrels, according to the U.S. Energy Department. Only the Netherlands and U.K. shipped more."Dieselization and its discontents. Tara Patel at Bloomberg has the related story that the closure of the Fos and Lavera oil terminals at Marseilles has left 13 oil tankers and 22 carriers of refined products stuck offshore. The La Mede refinery gets its feedstock by this port.
16. Tom Liodice at the Barrel reports that Philip Verleger, in the most recent edition of his "Notes at the Margin," believes that OPEC will need to cut production allocations by 7.7 million barrels in order to restore market balance. 7.7 million barrels!
"Here's why, according to Verleger:Verleger also argues that current global stocks are probably around 61-2 days--much more than OPEC estimates of around 55 days--and that by December 17 stocks may hold 65 days-worth of consumption. It is worth noting, I think, that Verleger's low-case scenario in early Fall was $10/b--which most thought astoundingly low. (His high price scenario was $250/b, which made the entire projection thing just a bit difficult to take seriously, however.)
-Global demand is down in December year-over-year by 5.2 million b/d to 81.6 million b/d, from 86.8 million b/d.
-Non-OPEC production is projected at 49.4 million b/d, with OPEC NGLs at 5.2 million b/d, and processing gain at 2.3 million b/d.
Verleger says that after adding those numbers, the call on OPEC is at 23.7 million b/d. By contrast, Platts' estimate of OPEC production in October was 32.26 million b/d, before its recent cut of 1.5 million b/d reached at a meeting in November. A call of 23.7 million b/d would stand in stark contrast to the IEA's estimate of a fourth quarter call of 31.1 million b/d and a full 2009 average of 30.4 million b/d."
Verleger believes that the current contango is due to nearly all available storage being full, meaning that there are few places still available to put oil bought today to profit from the contango. This puts further downward pressure on the spot price of oil because so little will be bought for future use--most must be sent to refineries for throughput now. The EIA data suggests otherwise, but clearly Verleger thinks the data--IEA, EIA, and OPEC--is all wrong, by 6-7 days worth of consumption, or 492-574 million barrels wrong (given consumption of 82 mb/d as opposed to, say, EIA 2009 projections of 85 mb/d). That's mighty wrong. (Still he seems to think that there may be enough room for an additional 255 million barrels.)
People pay Verleger plenty of money for his observations--and me I put these out for free, so take it for what it's worth, but I think he is probably wrong about this. Still, even more reason to suspect that OPEC will cut deep in their December 17 meeting. And Jordan Burke at Bloomberg reports, Boone Pickens believes that OPEC will cut from 2 to 2.5 mb/d in that meeting. And the big news today is that the EIA's Short-Term Energy Outlook released today forecasts a 5.8% decline in US petroleum production consumption in 2008, or a whopping 1.2 mb/d! Global oil consumption is predicted to fall by 50 kb/d in 2008 and 450 kb/d in 2009. And, the EIA expects non-OPEC supply to grow for the first time in over five years by 410 kb/d, reversing a 310 kb/d decline in 2008. The EIA apparently expects the call on OPEC in 2009 to decrease by precisely that--860 kb/d. Wednesday's EIA stocks numbers may be a decisive factor in the December 17 meeting.
17. Eurointelligence reports that yields on the three month treasury bill are now half a basis point, or 0.005%. The latest issue was three times oversubscribed.